LINUX NEWBIE ADMINISTRATOR GUIDE

ver. 0.38 1999-05-02

Part 0: For the Undecided (Linux Benefits)

by Peter,  Stan,  Barbara and Marie Klimas

Answers to Some Frequently Asked Linux Questions
Distributed under the General Public License http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/gpl.html. Your feedback, comments, corrections, and improvements are appreciated. Send them to either bklimas@magma.ca or bw641@freenet.carleton.ca



Quick site navigation:

Start:   Linux Newbie Administrator Guide
Part 0: >For the Undecided (Linux Benefits)<
Part 1: Before Linux Installation
Part 2: Linux Resources, Help and Some Links
Part 3: Basic Operations FAQ
Part 4: Linux Newbie Administrator FAQ
Part 5: How to Upgrade the Kernel
Part 6: Linux Shortcuts and Commands
Part 7: Essential Linux applications (proprietary or not)


Contents of this page:

0. For the Undecided (Linux Benefits)

0.1 Fundamentally, why Linux?
0.2 Is Linux for me?
0.3 What are the Linux benefits?
0.4 I don't believe in free software, etc.
0.5 "There ain't no thing as a free lunch"
0.6 I need high security. With commercial software, I can sue them if things go wrong.
0.7 I need standards. Big software corporations (Microsoft) provide standards.

0. For the Undecided (Linux Benefits)

0.1 Fundamentally, why Linux?

If you truly enjoy working with computers, Linux is the operating system of your dreams. It is more fun than any other operating system around. However, the reason why Linux is truly revolutionary is that it is Open Software. Our science and technology works owing to the free availability of information and peer review. Would you fly a plane that was based on proprietary science and unreviewed design, a plane at the internals of which nobody but the manufacturer could even look? Then, why would you trust a closed, unreviewed, proprietary operating system? Linux is ideally suited for a mission-critical application.

Making horseshoes was once a closely guarded trade secret. Science and technology exploded 500 years ago thanks to sharing the knowledge by the means of printing. In the early days of printing, many of those who dared to share were assassinated for revealing "trade secrets". For the computer age, Linux is what Gutenberg was for writing. Hopefully there will be no assassinations this time :-) .

0.2 Is Linux for me?
Only you can answer this question. Linux is a mature, powerful and versatile UNIX-like operating system. The power and versatility come with a price--you may need to be computer-literate in order to set-up and maintain Linux. Linux is relatively easy to use once the operating system and applications are set up properly, so your mother will also be able to use Linux if you set up an easy graphical account for her and put the proper icons/menus on her GUI desktop.  Linux is secure, so your mother will not be able to damage the system no matter how hard she tries (unless it's with a hammer :-) .

Linux is quite different than MS Windows so do not expect that if you can get around MS Windows, Linux will be obvious to you. You may need to learn. On the other hand, if you come from UNIX, Linux will be easy for you. If you don't know much about computers or you don't enjoy them, chances are Linux administration is not for you. If you don't know your hardware, Linux installation may be a challenge for you.

0.3 What are the Linux benefits?
Linux can give you:

o A modern and very stable multi-user, multitasking environment on your inexpensive PC hardware, at no price for the software. Linux is a rich and powerful platform--don't think of it as a "poor people" operating system.  Out-of-box Linux has as much capability as MS Windows NT with $5000 software add-ons, is more stable, and requires less powerful hardware for comparable tasks.

o Unsurpassed computing power, portability, and flexibility.  A Linux cluster recently (April 1999) beat a Cray supercomputer in a standard benchmark.  Linux is VERY standard--it is essentially a POSIX compliant UNIX.  (Yes, Linux is a best-of-the-breed UNIX. The word "UNIX" is not used in conjunction with Linux because "UNIX" is a trademark.) Linux is most popular on Intel-based PCs (price), but it runs equally well on numerous other platforms.

o Excellent networking capability built right into your operating system. You think you don't need a network? Once you try home networking, you will never be able to live without it!  What about connecting the two or more computers that you have at home and sharing your hard drives, CDROM(s), sound card(s), modem, printer(s), etc. What about browsing the net on two or more machines at the same time using a single Internet connection? What about playing a game with your son over the network? Even your 386 with Win3.11 may become useful again when connected to your Linux Pentium server so it is able to use your network resources. All necessary networking software comes with standard Linux, free, just setup is required. And it is not a second-gear shareware--it is exactly the same software that runs the Internet. The pleasure of home networking is something I was able to discover only owing to Linux.

o Connectivity to Microsoft, Novel, and Apple proprietary networking. Reading/writing to your DOS/MS Windows and other disk formats. This includes "transparent" use of data stored on the MS Windows partition on your hard drive.

o Dozens of excellent and free general-interest applications.

o Hundreds of specialized applications built by researchers around the world (astronomy, information technology, chemistry, physics, engineering, linguistics, biology, ...). In many fields, Linux seems like "the only" operating system in existence. The software in this category is typically not very easy to use, but if you want the power, it is the best software that humanity has in these areas. Doubtful? Have a look at: http://SAL.KachinaTech.COM/Z/2/index.shtml
for examples.

o Thousands of free applets, tools, and smaller programs. "Small is beautiful" goes well with Linux philosophy.

o Scores of commercial programs including Word Perfect and all the big databases (e.g., Oracle, Sybase, but no Microsoft's).  Many (most?) of these are offered free for developers and for personal use.

o State-of-art development platform with many best-of-the-kind programming languages and tools coming free with the operating system. Access to all the operating system source codes, if you require it, is also free.

o Freedom from viruses, software manufactures "features", invasion of privacy,  forced upgrades, licensing and marketing schemes, high software prices, and pirating. How is this?  Linux has no viruses because it is too secure an operating system for the viruses to spread with any degree of efficiency. The rest follows from the open-source and non-commercial nature of Linux.

o The operating platform that is guaranteed "here-to-stay". Since Linux is not owned, it cannot possibly be put out of business. The Linux General Public License (GPL) insures that development and support will be provided as long as there are Linux users.

o A platform which will technically develop at a rapid pace. This is insured by the modern, open-software development model which Linux implements:  "build-on-the-back-of the-previous-developer" and  "peer-review-your-code"  (as opposed to the anachronistic closed-software model: "always-start-from-scratch" and "nobody-will-see-my-code"). Even if the current "Linux-hype" died out, Linux will develop as it did before the media hype started.

If you wanted to learn first-hand about the General Public License, check these famous GNU documents:
http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/gpl.html
http://www.gnu.org/gnu/linux-and-gnu.html
http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/categories.html#TheGNUsystem
 

0.4  I don't believe in free software, etc.
And do you believe in the Internet? Internet and Linux share underlying ideas and have common roots. Do you remember the disbelief about the Internet a few years ago, the endless, seemingly unbeatable arguments that the free Internet cannot exist? "Who pays for that, anyway?"
0.5 "There ain't no thing as a free lunch"
Brett Bazant <bbazant@shaw.wave.ca> wrote in LinuxToday (http://linuxtoday.com/cgi-bin/showtb.pl?tbsn=12450&sn=5418):
The economic paradigm which makes this true depends upon scarcity of resources. Software resources are only scarce because we all keep software proprietary and secret. But not Linux! When I give you my software, it may create opportunity cost for me, but I get to keep it even after I've given it to you. It is a free lunch only rivalled in history by the loaves and the fishes.
0.6  I need high security. With commercial software, I can sue them if things go wrong.
Don't count on suing. Things go wrong on many MS Windows NT machines every day, and there are no damages awarded by courts.  Read your MS Windows license agreement to find that there is no guarantee whatsoever that ANYTHING will work. Trying to sue would be a waste of your money.

Linux  also provides no guarantees, although it is far more secure than any version of MS Windows.  If you are really security-sensitive , you can use high-security tools built by companies that rely on the availability of the source code to design and test their security features (e.g., Kryptokom in Germany provides high security firewalls).  The "security in obscurity" implemented in MS Windows has repeatedly been demonstrated to be a naive approach.

Here is a quote from David Kastrup, Research Engineer, Bochum, Germany (after the "Internet Week", http://www.techweb.com/se/directlink.cgi?INW19990329S0050):

"Risk aversion is what dictates you use Linux and other open products, rather than NT. The risks with NT are entirely out of your control, and there is nobody you could sue if anything goes wrong. Why people still believe the myth that Windows in any form offers any bit of accountability "more" than Linux remains a complete riddle to me."
0.7 I need standards. Big software corporations (Microsoft)  provide standards.
Perhaps that's what people would expect from big corporations, but the reality is rather different.  Once, big companies loved inventing nuts that could be undone only by their own service shops. Did these nuts become standard? Hardly. They didn't because there was no public benefit involved, and they couldn't because they were patented. Luckily, now we have open and free standards for nuts.

An example from the computer field.  The "standard" MS Word file format has changed so many times over the recent years that it can hardly be called a standard. This happens probably for a good business reason:  as soon as other companies "reverse-engineer" the current Word format,  Microsoft changes it. There are even sub-formats (a MS "fast-save" anybody?). It is also completely closed--Microsoft does not publish the specifications. How can the user benefit from this in a longer term?

There are a few other text/document oriented file formats that are quite definitely more standard than that:  ASCII, HTML, PostScript, pdf, TEX, dvi, SGML .... and all of them have excellent support under Linux.  The Word file format can be also read/written  very well by Word Perfect, Star Office, Applixware, etc. to cover your today's needs (but, please, don't call it a standard).

The story is similar with other big corporation computing "standards".  Linux, by its very nature, is based on true, published, and free standards. The very idea of "open source" is that it makes its full specification available to everybody (competitors or not).


Go to Part 1:  Before Linux Installation